DECCAN CHRONICLE | M R VENKATESH
Published Jan 25, 2016,
The great 18th century thinker Immanuel Kant may show the way to gradual peace.
Dr Lucas Thorpe
Chennai: Strange are the ways time moves in the digital age. The past could as much be a window to the future as the present in recreating trust.
Just when the Maithripala Sirisena-Ranil Wickramesinghe current dispensation in Sri Lanka has taken the first steps for drawing up a new Constitution, raising hopes for a lasting peace to the long-suffering and embattled Sri Lankan Tamils, Immanuel Kant, the 18th century German philosopher and a great find of the European Enlightenment age, may hold the key to that happy peace, even if popular perceptions have often dismissed him as being conservative and obscure.
It is partly because it is not fashionable these days to discuss Kant’s political philosophy. But, equally, not many may have come across the fact that the ideas articulated in a seminal article, ‘Towards Perpetual Peace’, this humble son of a ‘harness maker’ of Konigsberg had written in 1795, had substantially influenced the people who wrote the United Nations charter after World War-II had ended.
Throwing light on this aspect of Kant’s thinking, Dr Lucas Thorpe, Assistant Professor of Philosophy of Bogazici University in Istanbul, Turkey, at an interaction here recently at the Philosophy Department of Madras Christian College and its Centre for Peace Studies, said in trying to understand the roots of conflict between men and societies, Kant saw that often competing ostensibly moral positions was the mischief-maker, more so in relations between states.
As “you can have conflicts where both parties are in the right,” recognising the ‘justice of the other side’, was in Kant’s view, the first step to resolving conflicts, explained Dr Lucas. So this oft-touted justification of ‘going to war to achieve peace’ — as trumpeted during the U.S.’s invasion of Iraq — would have been straight rejected by Kant.
The idea of a ‘single World government’ was also rejected by Kant, as “religious and linguistic differences” would make such a ‘World State’ impossible, said Dr Lucas. Peace is possible only through a ‘Federation of Nations’.
For Kant, individual, personal morality should not be mixed up with the demands of a state and the best road to ‘perpetual and lasting peace’ was ‘creating specific institutions that created the conditions for peace’, as Dr Lucas elucidated. Kant’s insight was that establishing such specific institutions (internationally), going beyond personal moral / cultural barriers, logically create ‘conditions for peace’. This is one reason why rule-bound International trade is crucial for world peace.
“India is one of the most culturally pluralist country I have been to,” said Dr Lucas, who finds in Kant a “moral pluralist”. This reading of Kant surprises many scholars, he said in a conversation with Deccan Chronicle later. In man trying to “get out of the state of nature”, do you use violence to resolve conflicts or through Law? Kant there was more influenced by Jean Jacques Rousseau and preferred the social contract way to achieve ‘Justice, a humane outlook that later influenced great contemporary philosophers like John Rawls and Amartya Sen.
Landing here from Turkey, where a civil war has re-started rudely setting aside a two-year peace process that had raised hopes for the Kurdish minorities, after the spillover from the Syrian conflict, Dr Lucas said the signs of normalcy in Sri Lanka ‘looked a lot better’ situation than what was happening in Turkey now, though each intra-state conflict situation has its own history and specific features.
From a Kantian perspective, the biggest challenge is, “to establish peace, is to establish trust”, he stressed. When asked about its relevance to resolving the Tamils ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka, he said a key strand of the Kantian approach was that the parties in conflict ‘must recognise the justice of the other side’, if linguistic/cultural pride was not to degenerate into despotism.
“To make peace, you must assume the other person is good, willing and also incorporate the happiness of others,” noted Dr Lucas. “In the modern world, when there are multiple identities, if you believe in culture pride, you should also be aware of culture shame, the mistakes a culture may have made,” the candid philosopher from Istanbul mused.
Equally important is to appreciate that “pride of one’s culture does not entail a rigid view of other cultures,” he said.
“I am British by birth, but my wife is Turkish and learning to respect the other’s culture is very important,” Dr Lucas said, smilingly turning to his better half, Zubeyde Karadag Thorpe.
The notion of a ‘strong, unitary state’ posed problems in different parts of the world, particularly vis-à-vis group rights of ethnic/religious minorities.
Even in Sri Lanka, as it rewrites its Constitution, a “federal political settlement” and granting more autonomy could be the only long-term solution, he said. But this has to be “achieved step by step,” by a ‘gradualism’ that Kant believed in.
This syndrome of ‘creating heaven on earth in one stroke’ has to go, to “avoid the dangers of being a racist or a nationalist”, Dr Thorpe reasoned. Hope Colombo is listening too.
» CCS.N0000 ( Ceylon Cold Stores)
» Sri Lanka plans to allow tourists from August, no mandatory quarantine
» When Will It Be Safe To Invest In The Stock Market Again?
» Dividend Announcements
» MAINTENANCE NOTICE / නඩත්තු දැනුම්දීම
» ඩොලර් මිලියනයක මුදල් සම්මානයක් සහ “ෆීල්ඩ්ස් පදක්කම” පිළිගැනීම ප්රතික්ෂේප කළ ගණිතඥයා
» SEYB.N0000 (Seylan Bank PLC)
» Here's what blind prophet Baba Vanga predicted for 2016 and beyond: It's not good
» The Korean Way !
» In the Meantime Within Our Shores!
» What is Known as Dementia?
» SRI LANKA TELECOM PLC (SLTL.N0000)
» THE LANKA HOSPITALS CORPORATION PLC (LHCL.N0000)
» Equinox ( වසන්ත විෂුවය ) !
» COMB.N0000 (Commercial Bank of Ceylon PLC)
» REXP.N0000 (Richard Pieris Exports PLC)
» RICH.N0000 (Richard Pieris and Company PLC)
» Do You Have Computer Vision Syndrome?
» LAXAPANA BATTERIES PLC (LITE.N0000)
» What a Bank Run ?
» 104 Technical trading experiments by HUNTER
» GLAS.N0000 (Piramal Glass Ceylon PLC)
» Cboe Volatility Index
» AHPL.N0000
» TJL.N0000 (Tee Jey Lanka PLC.)
» CTBL.N0000 ( CEYLON TEA BROKERS PLC)
» COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY PLC (COMD. N.0000))
» Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency
» CSD.N0000 (Seylan Developments PLC)
» PLC.N0000 (People's Leasing and Finance PLC)
» Bakery Products ?
» NTB.N0000 (Nations Trust Bank PLC)
» Going South
» When Seagulls Follow the Trawler
» Re-activating
» අපි තමයි හොඳටම කරේ !
» මේ අර් බුධය කිසිසේත්ම මා විසින් නිර්මාණය කල එකක් නොවේ
» SAMP.N0000 (Sampath Bank PLC)
» APLA.N0000 (ACL Plastics PLC)
» AVOID FALLING INTO ALLURING WEEKEND FAMILY PACKAGES.
» Banks, Finance & Insurance Sector Chart
» VPEL.N0000 (Vallibel Power Erathna PLC)
» DEADLY COCKTAIL OF ISLAND MENTALITY AND PARANOID PERSONALITY DISORDER MIX.
» WATA - Watawala
» KFP.N0000(Keels Food Products PLC)
» Capital Trust Broker in difficulty?
» IS PIRATING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY A BOON OR BANE?
» What Industry Would You Choose to Focus?
» Should I Stick Around, or Should I Follow Others' Lead?