The Investor Sentiment - Equity and investments forum for Sri Lankans



Join the forum, it's quick and easy

The Investor Sentiment - Equity and investments forum for Sri Lankans

The Investor Sentiment - Equity and investments forum for Sri Lankans

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
The Investor Sentiment - Equity and investments forum for Sri Lankans

The Lankan Investor Forum - A more respectable and reasonable place for members to discuss matters regarding the CSEThe Lankan Investor Forum - A more respectable and reasonable place for members to discuss matters regarding the CSE

Please send an email to contact.lankaninvestor@gmail.com if you face any technical difficulties when posting

Latest topics

» CCS.N0000 ( Ceylon Cold Stores)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 20, 2024 11:31 am by Hawk Eye

» Sri Lanka plans to allow tourists from August, no mandatory quarantine
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 13, 2023 12:16 pm by lauryfriese

» When Will It Be Safe To Invest In The Stock Market Again?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Apr 19, 2023 6:41 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Dividend Announcements
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Apr 12, 2023 5:41 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» MAINTENANCE NOTICE / නඩත්තු දැනුම්දීම
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Apr 06, 2023 3:18 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» ඩොලර් මිලියනයක මුදල් සම්මානයක් සහ “ෆීල්ඩ්ස් පදක්කම” පිළිගැනීම ප්‍රතික්ෂේප කළ ගණිතඥයා
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Apr 02, 2023 7:28 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» SEYB.N0000 (Seylan Bank PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 30, 2023 9:25 am by yellow knife

» Here's what blind prophet Baba Vanga predicted for 2016 and beyond: It's not good
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 30, 2023 9:25 am by HaeroMaero

» The Korean Way !
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 29, 2023 7:09 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» In the Meantime Within Our Shores!
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 27, 2023 5:51 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» What is Known as Dementia?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Mar 24, 2023 10:09 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» SRI LANKA TELECOM PLC (SLTL.N0000)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 20, 2023 5:18 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» THE LANKA HOSPITALS CORPORATION PLC (LHCL.N0000)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 20, 2023 5:10 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Equinox ( වසන්ත විෂුවය ) !
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 20, 2023 4:28 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» COMB.N0000 (Commercial Bank of Ceylon PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 19, 2023 4:11 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» REXP.N0000 (Richard Pieris Exports PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 19, 2023 4:02 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» RICH.N0000 (Richard Pieris and Company PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 19, 2023 3:53 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Do You Have Computer Vision Syndrome?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySat Mar 18, 2023 7:36 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» LAXAPANA BATTERIES PLC (LITE.N0000)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 16, 2023 11:23 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» What a Bank Run ?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 15, 2023 5:33 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» 104 Technical trading experiments by HUNTER
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 15, 2023 4:27 pm by katesmith1304

» GLAS.N0000 (Piramal Glass Ceylon PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 15, 2023 7:45 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Cboe Volatility Index
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Mar 14, 2023 5:32 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» AHPL.N0000
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 12, 2023 4:46 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» TJL.N0000 (Tee Jey Lanka PLC.)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 12, 2023 4:43 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» CTBL.N0000 ( CEYLON TEA BROKERS PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 12, 2023 4:41 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY PLC (COMD. N.0000))
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Mar 10, 2023 4:43 pm by yellow knife

» Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Mar 10, 2023 1:47 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» CSD.N0000 (Seylan Developments PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Mar 10, 2023 10:38 am by yellow knife

» PLC.N0000 (People's Leasing and Finance PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 09, 2023 8:02 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Bakery Products ?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 08, 2023 5:30 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» NTB.N0000 (Nations Trust Bank PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 05, 2023 7:24 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Going South
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySat Mar 04, 2023 10:47 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» When Seagulls Follow the Trawler
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 02, 2023 10:22 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Re-activating
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySat Feb 25, 2023 5:12 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» අපි තමයි හොඳටම කරේ !
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Feb 14, 2023 3:54 pm by ruwan326

» මේ අර් බුධය කිසිසේත්ම මා විසින් නිර්මාණය කල එකක් නොවේ
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Jan 03, 2023 6:43 pm by ruwan326

» SAMP.N0000 (Sampath Bank PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Nov 30, 2022 8:24 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» APLA.N0000 (ACL Plastics PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Nov 18, 2022 7:49 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» AVOID FALLING INTO ALLURING WEEKEND FAMILY PACKAGES.
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyWed Nov 16, 2022 9:28 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Banks, Finance & Insurance Sector Chart
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Nov 15, 2022 5:26 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» VPEL.N0000 (Vallibel Power Erathna PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySun Nov 13, 2022 12:15 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» DEADLY COCKTAIL OF ISLAND MENTALITY AND PARANOID PERSONALITY DISORDER MIX.
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyMon Nov 07, 2022 6:36 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» WATA - Watawala
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySat Nov 05, 2022 8:44 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» KFP.N0000(Keels Food Products PLC)
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptySat Nov 05, 2022 8:42 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Capital Trust Broker in difficulty?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyFri Oct 21, 2022 5:25 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» IS PIRATING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY A BOON OR BANE?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Oct 20, 2022 10:13 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» What Industry Would You Choose to Focus?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Oct 11, 2022 6:39 pm by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Should I Stick Around, or Should I Follow Others' Lead?
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyTue Oct 11, 2022 9:07 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» DV-2024 Program: Online Registration
COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 EmptyThu Oct 06, 2022 11:26 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

Disclaimer


Information posted in this forum are entirely of the respective members' personal views. The views posted on this open online forum of contributors do not constitute a recommendation buy or sell. The site nor the connected parties will be responsible for the posts posted on the forum and will take best possible action to remove any unlawful or inappropriate posts.
All rights to articles of value authored by members posted on the forum belong to the respective authors. Re-using without the consent of the authors is prohibited. Due credit with links to original source should be given when quoting content from the forum.
This is an educational portal and not one that gives recommendations. Please obtain investment advises from a Registered Investment Advisor through a stock broker

+11
Illusion
stocks hunter
WARREN BSL
girihell
pathfinder
smallville
windi5
serene
First Guy
slstock
shane101
15 posters

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    First Guy
    First Guy


    Posts : 2599
    Join date : 2014-02-22

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by First Guy Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:10 pm

    I have not gone through the sections of the act but I also share The Alchemist's views. It's a case of ethics and laws intertwines. When we speak of ethics, we merely see that they are trying to buy TFIL @ 28 when it is trading at 40, but why did it go to 40 in the first place?

    * Even at 28/- I feel TFIL got a very good multiple for the acquisition, maybe even better than expected.

    * With the acquisition of that major stake, the free float reduced dramatically, in turn the trades of retailers sending the share price soaring. I don't think it is justified in any way though.

    * Imagine a situation where a company with very little free float being manipulated by the 'minority shareholders' and expect a higher price when being de-listed?

    * Imagine a company like GSF willing to pay 500 - 600/- per share if it had gone for de-listing at that time?

    * One dilemma is that COCR gave a mandatory offer at 28/- to which many would have subscribed and now if they go for a higher price to de-list, it is not fair for those who accepted the offer. COCR can, though pay the higher price to all but it may not be worth it for them.

    * Finally, it's always safe to pay for the value instead of over-paying. Usually such big acquisitions are already done at premiums by the big guys who can benefit from synergies. It may not be worth for retailers to pay the same price or more.
    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:32 pm

    Reply in Red


    The Alchemist wrote:A interesting case where ethical and legal issues are intertwined. btw, COCR company secretary Jaycee = Julius & Creasy = CFLB Group Smile   

    Just some points that come to mind. 

    1. When COCR bought out The Cooray Family interest in TFIL @ Rs 28, over 96 %, they established the price at Rs 28/ = for any future mandatory offer de-listing price. So simply and just because the price re-rated afterwards to the 40's should not make them liable to pay that incremental price. 

    No they don't have to offer higher than Rs 28 voluntarily if they  want to buy remaining shares.

    But just as that is an option to them , at the same time minority  shareholders should not be forced to  sell at the rate they want .  If possible they can say Rs 20 even  ( fortunately they can't do that)



    2. Since we have no idea whether of future plans of COCR re TFIL i.e. leave it as a standalone company (subsidiary) or merge with it, we cannot expect them to for eg give TFIL shareholders COCR shares.

    Yes we don't know the plans for sure. Could guess only


    3. Since there is a new mandatory free float law of 20 % and since post acquisition, it does not comply with it, and COCR may have no desire to increase Free-float of TIFL to seek compliance, then a mandatory de-listing maybe the eventual option. 

     That can happen

    4. Prior to delisting, Since the New Companies Act seems to offer COCR a remedy to forcibly buy-over remaining shares at mandatory offer price ??? IF none of the remaining shareholders objects within 2 weeks (remedy is provided), they could do so however unethical it seems. 


    This is the question asked . Is the companies act proving them the power when  no other company has done it including LAMB, SHAL, GOOD etc .  

    Note the comments I made regarding the contract,scheme and majority decision.  If there are 50 minority share holders can 1 top holder over rule all of them and do their bidding?  This sets a very very dangerous precedence if this ACT has a loop hole and is allowed.


    Note the Sec 246 applies for amalgamation.   COCR has not issues any notice about amalgamation as per Sec 240 onwards. Then they directly quote 246 now.  

    Also  when delisting time comes ( that is another matter) what are the rules that apply to delisting?  
    Thats when  LAMB, SHAL,CDIC actions comes to play.  We need to dig deeper.

    Also if they are so sure they can  take over minority shares by brute force ( certainly a terrible practice if allowed by authorties), why did they not disclose it during  the mandatory offer or extended mandatory offer?  
    Why wait till now and do  all this drama?  



    5. Perhaps the reason why COCR does not want to straightaway delist is because there maybe some clauses about a weighted average market prices etc in preceding 3 month prior (higher than Rs 28) but i doubt it since over 95 % was acquired at Rs 28. (or maybe even an independent valuation).       

    Yes


    6. The remedy is prescribed in the company's Act to seek relief from court within a two week period. but who except for Mr. Vignarajah will incur costs and do it ? 


    Again question is whether COCR is abusing  Sec 246 or  found a loop hole
    or made this forceful letter  not following  the proper steps?


    CSE and SEC should play a role in this to clarify minority holders. yes am not sure how many there how can spend on court fees. .  Minority holder should query SEC /CSE also.
    Thats what SEC did when PCHH issue came.  




    7. Furthermore, besides the ethical issues, is it really worth it ? based on TIFL fundamentals (and if the majority Cooray Family saw fit to sell controlling stake at Rs 28), who can argue with that. Furthermore, if anyone feels TFIL is undervalued at Rs 28/-, they have the option of buying COCR, although i have not studied the valuations post acquisition.  





    This is separate matter.


    a) From our perspective:
     over valued or not at Rs 40 is an  interesting question. Eps will be around Rs 3.5 this year, NAV about RS 15 now. Fundamentally I would  value it now around Rs 32-35  giving an edge over GSF , Chilaw , MFL etc) looking at the consistant growth factor and earnings, dividends .

    But yes there are more attractive shares in the market.  But also the present  COCR valuation,  and people expecting COCR to go to Rs 60 will be a bigger question.  GSF at Rs 30 will be question.   Many examples.
    But yes the play now is more speculative  than fundamental and whether it valued much over Rs 35- 40 is arguable.

    b) issue :  

    But that is not the matter here. The matter is can they use brute force to make every one sell at the price they want when a mandatory offer is over.  What are minority share holder rights?  This is legal point no one here can answer looking at the wording on Sec 246.


    I see people now arguing whether it is overvalued at over Rs 28 or not. That is not the matter. Also yes I agree COCR don't have to pay Rs 40. NDB did not have to offer Rs 600 either. LAMB did not force share holders either.

    So there is a legal , ethical matter entangled here I agree.  


    8. In Principle, their should be an option to remain as a shareholder of TFIL although it is mandatorily de-listed. (i know many people who are still shareholders for eg of Walker Tours even after JKH gave share swap for KHL and delisted Walker Tours).

    Agreed


    Last edited by slstock on Sun Nov 09, 2014 9:18 pm; edited 2 times in total
    avatar
    Top Trader
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 155
    Join date : 2014-03-06

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by Top Trader Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:45 pm

    slstock wrote:I read the sinhalese and english versions of the companies act sec 246. ( to best of my understanding) .

    To start and add further light, let us consider CDIC case where NDB  wanted to delist CDIC.

    They did a share buy back , at Rs 545  in 2013
    When they intended to delist, they made  public announcement and offered Rs 600 ( which was much more beneficial to share holders ) than the market traded price of Rs 499.9 then. So ofcourse CDIC minority benefits by accepting it. why shouldn't they.  

    In this case let look at TFIL  case.

    1)  TFIL was independant company operating and listed under CSE. COCR wanted to merge or absorb  TFIL  according to CB merger/acquisition  directives  before delisting.  unlike CDIC  (which is now going to be Limited company).  

    To do this their offers needs to be even more attractive to what  CDIC  or KURU did for delisting is it not? People what do you think?  

    2)  Let study TFIL history

      a)  For TFIL  they gave a  mandatory offer at Rs 28
      b) at that time COCR was trading in early rs 20s mind you( less than TFIL)
      c) Then they jacked up COCR to beyond TFIL value.
         ( both are having similar Net asset values. COCR eps maybe a bit more though)
      d)  Then  they offered an extended mandatory offer at RS 28 for TFIL while making
           COCR prices even going up higher to over Rs 40s.  
     e) At the end of extended mandatory offer at Rs 28 for TFIL, naturally there were people who did not want to sell at a low Rs 28
       ( note these shares are listed at CDS also , not just anywhere)
    f) Then TFIL shot up to meet  COCR values in Rs 40s for obvious reasons


    Now what COCR is trying to do,

    1)  From what I see is COCR is trying to  misquote  the Companies act to their benefit,   offer lower prices than trading at market ( Rs 40) for TFIL to scare minority to buy them at Rs 28 which they could not get at a mandatory offer.


    Here is another instance of the mis use. What if COCR got less than 90% of TFIL. They will not be in a position to even quote the Sec 246.
    Now because they got thew power , they say lets abuse it.

    2)  Note Companies act Sec 246
     a)  falls under section for amalgamation of companies. Where is the disclosure for such?
     b)  says  " notice in the prescribed manner to all the shareholders
    holding the outstanding shares carrying voting rights, the desire to acquire such shares"

     It means to request outstanding share holders they would like to but not to forcefully  to take over their  CDS listed shares at below market prices!

    Clearly this is a clear abuse and violates minority share holder rights. This is purely unfair for all minority share holders.

    If this is allowed, any company who has more than 90% shares ( like CDIC , KURU, SHAL, GOOD ) etc can forcefully prescribe an offer and take over all share of the minority at below market prices!!!!  There won't be any need for SEC or small time investors.


    I think some shareholder of TFIL in Sri Lanka ( also Mr Vignarajah time to fight ) should file a complaint at the court soon as possible to stop this abuse.  Else this will be trend and so bad for CSE.

    SEC should  interpret what COCR is trying to do here and the safeguard the minority shareholders. It is their  duty.



    Also can someone in the legal sector please read and interpret Sec  246. It will be public service.

    Its happy to see the long explanation given to the members benefit, as you said its an desire only allowed in the Companies Act, and if am not mistaken in one instance in a seminar organised by a Professional Body in SL, an the mergers or consolidation of the financial sector a CA cum Lawyer, explain this, saying once you buy a share you are the shareholder for Life. So i personally feel they should withdraw this letter, while making an apology, if not all the shareholders of the companies where Jacey & Company function as Secretaries must be very careful in the future.

    Also if am not mistaken, recently Cargills bank announce its intention of exchange its share for the balance CALF shares and they appointed some independent body to do the valuation to determine the basis of exchange.

    I feel the purpose of this letter is to scared the balance shareholders, and they might arrange some parties to buy the shares subsequent to this notice.

    If they allowed to take over by force, by overcoming the laws and protection for the minority shareholders right it be the end for the share market.

    Also in a personal note, COCR shareholders be watchful about the company, because tomorrow they might write to their own shares as well

    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:54 pm

    I am not talking about then.

    I am talking about now , COCR trying to force rest of the share holders to sell at the price they want forcibly.


    If they were so sure they could take over by force they could have disclosed at the last mandatory offer,
    that " if people did not give up their share at Rs 28 they will take it forcibly. They waited till COCR priced went up. TFIL followed on speculation I agree. I explained this more in the answer to alchemist.

    Leaving other matters on COCR, question now is what COCR is doing is legal though not ethical.

    Btw, when Mandatory offer announcement came
    TFIL had already hit Rs 28
    COCR price was about Rs 25.

    To me both share were manipulated.




    stocks hunter wrote:
    slstock wrote:Now what COCR is trying to do,

    1) From what I see is COCR is trying to misquote the Companies act to their benefit, offer lower prices than trading at market ( Rs 40) for TFIL to scare minority to buy them at Rs 28 which they could not get at a mandatory offer.


    I'm not agreeing to this. To my simple knowledge when COCR published the offer price the trading price of TFIL was around Rs23 - Rs25. If this was @Rs40 levels at that time it is not ethical as sls said. But here nothing has happened like that.

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 BrowseCOCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Browse" />

    Manipulators are the main culprits here.

    Again this is my idea only. I may be wrong/correct. Time will tell everything.
    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Sun Nov 09, 2014 9:02 pm

    Thank you for reminding the CARG stand over CALF. You further exemplified the point here which I am trying to stress.
    It is not about TFIL current market price or whether COCR has to offer at higher prices. It about the way they went about this and and how forceful ways are used .

    People read the below,

    See what CARG is doing with CALF which has nearly half  the asset value ( Rs 8  )  of TFIL  
    http://www.cse.lk/cmt/uploadAnnounceFiles/7161412676094_1101.pdf

    But how is COCR behaving with TFIL.  This reminds me the 2 Gira Pothaya ( 2 little Parrots) story from buddhism.
    (Some people stated there was connection between TFIl and CALF. If it did ( I did not dig in) Seems they fell into different hands like in the story.) .

    Also for those concerned with TFIL values

    CALF is trading at Rs 17.5 when asset Rs 8  with losses
    I stated so many other examples. So leave the value aside, the matter is different.


    Top Trader wrote:
    slstock wrote:I read the sinhalese and english versions of the companies act sec 246. ( to best of my understanding) .

    To start and add further light, let us consider CDIC case where NDB  wanted to delist CDIC.

    They did a share buy back , at Rs 545  in 2013
    When they intended to delist, they made  public announcement and offered Rs 600 ( which was much more beneficial to share holders ) than the market traded price of Rs 499.9 then. So ofcourse CDIC minority benefits by accepting it. why shouldn't they.  

    In this case let look at TFIL  case.

    1)  TFIL was independant company operating and listed under CSE. COCR wanted to merge or absorb  TFIL  according to CB merger/acquisition  directives  before delisting.  unlike CDIC  (which is now going to be Limited company).  

    To do this their offers needs to be even more attractive to what  CDIC  or KURU did for delisting is it not? People what do you think?  

    2)  Let study TFIL history

      a)  For TFIL  they gave a  mandatory offer at Rs 28
      b) at that time COCR was trading in early rs 20s mind you( less than TFIL)
      c) Then they jacked up COCR to beyond TFIL value.
         ( both are having similar Net asset values. COCR eps maybe a bit more though)
      d)  Then  they offered an extended mandatory offer at RS 28 for TFIL while making
           COCR prices even going up higher to over Rs 40s.  
     e) At the end of extended mandatory offer at Rs 28 for TFIL, naturally there were people who did not want to sell at a low Rs 28
       ( note these shares are listed at CDS also , not just anywhere)
    f) Then TFIL shot up to meet  COCR values in Rs 40s for obvious reasons


    Now what COCR is trying to do,

    1)  From what I see is COCR is trying to  misquote  the Companies act to their benefit,   offer lower prices than trading at market ( Rs 40) for TFIL to scare minority to buy them at Rs 28 which they could not get at a mandatory offer.


    Here is another instance of the mis use. What if COCR got less than 90% of TFIL. They will not be in a position to even quote the Sec 246.
    Now because they got thew power , they say lets abuse it.

    2)  Note Companies act Sec 246
     a)  falls under section for amalgamation of companies. Where is the disclosure for such?
     b)  says  " notice in the prescribed manner to all the shareholders
    holding the outstanding shares carrying voting rights, the desire to acquire such shares"

     It means to request outstanding share holders they would like to but not to forcefully  to take over their  CDS listed shares at below market prices!

    Clearly this is a clear abuse and violates minority share holder rights. This is purely unfair for all minority share holders.

    If this is allowed, any company who has more than 90% shares ( like CDIC , KURU, SHAL, GOOD ) etc can forcefully prescribe an offer and take over all share of the minority at below market prices!!!!  There won't be any need for SEC or small time investors.


    I think some shareholder of TFIL in Sri Lanka ( also Mr Vignarajah time to fight ) should file a complaint at the court soon as possible to stop this abuse.  Else this will be trend and so bad for CSE.

    SEC should  interpret what COCR is trying to do here and the safeguard the minority shareholders. It is their  duty.



    Also can someone in the legal sector please read and interpret Sec  246. It will be public service.

    Its happy to see the long explanation given to the members benefit, as you said its an desire only allowed in the Companies Act, and if am not mistaken in one instance in a seminar organised by a Professional Body in SL, an the mergers or consolidation of the financial sector a CA cum Lawyer, explain this, saying once you buy a share you are the shareholder for Life. So i personally feel they should withdraw this letter, while making an apology, if not all the shareholders of the companies where Jacey & Company function as Secretaries must be very careful in the future.

    Also if am not mistaken, recently Cargills bank announce its intention of exchange its share for the balance CALF shares and they appointed some independent body to do the valuation to determine the basis of exchange.

    I feel the purpose of this letter is to scared the balance shareholders, and they might arrange some parties to buy the shares subsequent to this notice.

    If they allowed to take over by force, by overcoming the laws and protection for the minority shareholders right it be the end for the share market.

    Also in a personal note, COCR shareholders be watchful about the company, because tomorrow they might write to their own shares as well

    avatar
    suja


    Posts : 88
    Join date : 2014-04-04

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by suja Mon Nov 10, 2014 12:34 pm

    SLS/Rest of the experts on this share, the share (TFIL Trade finance and investment) is trading at 34.70 levels I have some shares. Should I hold as I see value in this or should I sell. Now I am at a BE with this?
    avatar
    Top Trader
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 155
    Join date : 2014-03-06

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by Top Trader Mon Nov 10, 2014 1:44 pm

    http://www.cse.lk/cmt/upload_cse_announcements/7821415604504_.pdf
    avatar
    Top Trader
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 155
    Join date : 2014-03-06

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by Top Trader Mon Nov 10, 2014 1:50 pm

    I feel if they can do it, then COCR Shareholders must be very careful.

    Also shareholders of the companies, where more than 90% controlled by the major shareholders?
    avatar
    suja


    Posts : 88
    Join date : 2014-04-04

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by suja Mon Nov 10, 2014 2:47 pm

    Yes but this is an offer right?

    The minority shareholders have to sell at this price. What happens if they are not willing to sell at Rs.28 and want a higher price?
    avatar
    Top Trader
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 155
    Join date : 2014-03-06

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by Top Trader Mon Nov 10, 2014 3:10 pm

    suja wrote:Yes but this is an offer right?

    The minority shareholders have to sell at this price. What happens if they are not willing to sell at Rs.28 and want a higher price?

    By looking at the wording, it seems its not an offer, and a forced by back, am not sure and i don't have this share (Both)
    avatar
    girihell


    Posts : 131
    Join date : 2014-03-03

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by girihell Tue Nov 11, 2014 10:42 am

    very good and different views from many, thanks everybody for their views and a healthy discussion
    and it seems like what they wanted is happening, share price is dragging down
    I wonder how many people are stuck with prices above 40
    avatar
    suja


    Posts : 88
    Join date : 2014-04-04

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by suja Tue Nov 11, 2014 1:17 pm

    I have this share and now I am at a BE. But a company can not buy back forcefully from your CDS account.. FYI Top Trader.

    Maybe the government can do that which is not ethical like Pelwatte but not pvt companies.

    So I might not sell at 28 and see what happens.
    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Mon Dec 01, 2014 1:48 pm

    Anyone noticed anything interesting on TFIL over past 2 weeks? ( Nothing to do with COCR behavior which I have issues with)
    smallville
    smallville
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 1872
    Join date : 2014-02-23
    Location : Trying to figure out..

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by smallville Mon Dec 01, 2014 2:14 pm

    suja wrote:I have this share and now I am at a BE. But a company can not buy back forcefully from your CDS account.. FYI Top Trader.

    Maybe the government can do that which is not ethical like Pelwatte but not pvt companies.

    So I might not sell at 28 and see what happens.

    Read their announcement again.. Company will buy the remaining shares as of 4th Dec 2014 @ 28.. I think it will take a month to receive the cheque.
    WasteofTime
    WasteofTime


    Posts : 271
    Join date : 2014-09-29

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by WasteofTime Mon Dec 01, 2014 2:38 pm


    COCR price was strong and not affected much during last week market drops.Do you think thier is a possibilty to break from current level?

    slstock wrote:Anyone noticed anything interesting on TFIL over past 2 weeks?  ( Nothing to do with COCR behavior which I have issues with)
    avatar
    serene
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 4850
    Join date : 2014-02-26

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by serene Mon Dec 01, 2014 2:50 pm

    smallville wrote:
    suja wrote:I have this share and now I am at a BE. But a company can not buy back forcefully from your CDS account.. FYI Top Trader.

    Maybe the government can do that which is not ethical like Pelwatte but not pvt companies.

    So I might not sell at 28 and see what happens.

    Read their announcement again.. Company will buy the remaining shares as of 4th Dec 2014 @ 28.. I think it will take a month to receive the cheque.

    Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad
    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Mon Dec 01, 2014 3:15 pm

    Seems no one paid attention I guess.

    Let me tell you something very very interesting. There were only 800 thou shares in market when this massacre was announced. ( share price crashed from Rs 40s to 29) . Foreign holding was around 5000 shares.

    Do you know what happened?

    Foreigners bought continuously. So did they only buy below Rs 28? Yes some. But they collected over Rs 30 too!!

    Now they have 86000 shares ( as of frday) . ( that 10% of remainign shares in the market) .

    4 scenarios :


    1) they know something local don't ( If you remember I was very vociferous about this move by COCR to find loop holes
    in an ACT to behave like this. Whether is is legal or not is another issue. But it is very unethical. No other company
    did that to take over a company in this bad way also using unwanted language. I gave several example before of other companies which
    were not taken over this way by the acquiring group. Only COCR chose to behave this way)

    2) these foreigners are related to COCR ( but not disclosed) . Technically it will be violation of SEC rules , if they buy through foreign account and not disclose.. I know foreigner account ( who we don't know) bought over Rs 30. If they are related they TFIL has to offer over Rs 30 .
    So this is mystery.
    3) these forerigners are nuts

    4) these foreigner are planning to sell before Dec 4th ( but why should they sell cheaper than they bought?)

    I am watching the drama.

    Again I reiterate, I don't not approve COCR behaviour over this matter ( also their eps calculations , NAV were mis stated in the past).
    This is not how decent company should act. Yes they are growing ( for now) but that is another matter.





    slstock wrote:Anyone noticed anything interesting on TFIL over past 2 weeks? ( Nothing to do with COCR behavior which I have issues with)
    smallville
    smallville
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 1872
    Join date : 2014-02-23
    Location : Trying to figure out..

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by smallville Mon Dec 01, 2014 4:14 pm

    slstock wrote:

    1) they know something local don't ( If you remember I was very vociferous about this move by COCR to find loop holes
    in an ACT to behave like this. Whether is is legal or not is another issue. But it is  very unethical.  No other company
     did that to take over a company in this bad way also using unwanted  language. I gave several example before of other companies which
     were not taken over this way by the acquiring group. Only COCR chose to behave this way)

    2) these foreigners are related to COCR ( but not disclosed) . Technically it will be violation of SEC rules , if they buy through foreign account  and not disclose.. I know foreigner account ( who we don't know) bought over Rs 30. If they are related they  TFIL has to offer over Rs 30 .
     So this is mystery.
    3) these forerigners are  nuts

    4) these foreigner  are planning to sell  before Dec 4th ( but why should they sell cheaper than they bought?)


    1) If the company has to be delisted, TFIL has to be absorbed to COCR. That's why they are quoting a price 28/- as the mandatory price. After 4th December, they may halt trading, proceed with delisting.
    As of their last announcement, they hav 900K shares to be bought back for that and they will go ahead with the same figure since its unfair for the ppl who accept the manda offer if they raise the price and vice versa if they deduct it too. On the other hand its a must that they offer the highest price they bought to offer.
    Imo, in this case, the poor retailers who went after this like Tsunami are in trouble but company has nothing to do in this case.

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Tfil10

    4) On 4th, its worthwhile to watch the drama unfolds.. As per above excerpt, all reaming shares would go to COCR at 28/-. I think it will take a month or so to receive the cheque though.

    On the other hand, if for some reason, TFIL come down than 27, the company might buy this time as they missed it at 26 (still 2 rupees profit for them than buying from the shareholders).

    Let me tell u what Im gonna do.. I dont a give a damn abt the foreigners.. I will buy some quantity if it hits below 26 or hold what I have till 4th December as selling to them at 28 is a profit even if this doesn't go to 30s..
    slstock
    slstock
    Veteran
    Veteran


    Posts : 6216
    Join date : 2014-06-12

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by slstock Mon Dec 01, 2014 4:20 pm

    You will buy i this goes below Rs 26 now? It went to around Rs 24 last week. You best bet was then if you had money.

    Also whether you/we give damn about foreginer or not is not the issue here. Points discussed has other depth as you will note.


    smallville wrote:
    slstock wrote:

    1) they know something local don't ( If you remember I was very vociferous about this move by COCR to find loop holes
    in an ACT to behave like this. Whether is is legal or not is another issue. But it is  very unethical.  No other company
     did that to take over a company in this bad way also using unwanted  language. I gave several example before of other companies which
     were not taken over this way by the acquiring group. Only COCR chose to behave this way)

    2) these foreigners are related to COCR ( but not disclosed) . Technically it will be violation of SEC rules , if they buy through foreign account  and not disclose.. I know foreigner account ( who we don't know) bought over Rs 30. If they are related they  TFIL has to offer over Rs 30 .
     So this is mystery.
    3) these forerigners are  nuts

    4) these foreigner  are planning to sell  before Dec 4th ( but why should they sell cheaper than they bought?)


    1) If the company has to be delisted, TFIL has to be absorbed to COCR. That's why they are quoting a price 28/- as the mandatory price. After 4th December, they may halt trading, proceed with delisting.
    As of their last announcement, they hav 900K shares to be bought back for that and they will go ahead with the same figure since its unfair for the ppl who accept the manda offer if they raise the price and vice versa if they deduct it too. On the other hand its a must that they offer the highest price they bought to offer.
    Imo, in this case, the poor retailers who went after this like Tsunami are in trouble but company has nothing to do in this case.

    [url=/view/16185004/445]COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Tfil10[/url]

    4) On 4th, its worthwhile to watch the drama unfolds.. As per above excerpt, all reaming shares would go to COCR at 28/-. I think it will take a month or so to receive the cheque though.

    On the other hand, if for some reason, TFIL come down than 27, the company might buy this time as they missed it at 26 (still 2 rupees profit for them than buying from the shareholders).

    Let me tell u what Im gonna do.. I dont a give a damn abt the foreigners.. I will buy some quantity if it hits below 26 or hold what I have till 4th December as selling to them at 28 is a profit even if this doesn't go to 30s..
    avatar
    serene
    Top contributor
    Top contributor


    Posts : 4850
    Join date : 2014-02-26

    COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Empty Re: COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ?

    Post by serene Mon Dec 01, 2014 8:00 pm

    slstock wrote:You will buy i this goes below Rs 26 now?  It went to around Rs 24 last week. You best bet was then if you had money.

    Also whether you/we give damn about foreginer or not is not the issue here. Points discussed has other depth as you will note.


    smallville wrote:
    slstock wrote:

    1) they know something local don't ( If you remember I was very vociferous about this move by COCR to find loop holes
    in an ACT to behave like this. Whether is is legal or not is another issue. But it is  very unethical.  No other company
     did that to take over a company in this bad way also using unwanted  language. I gave several example before of other companies which
     were not taken over this way by the acquiring group. Only COCR chose to behave this way)

    2) these foreigners are related to COCR ( but not disclosed) . Technically it will be violation of SEC rules , if they buy through foreign account  and not disclose.. I know foreigner account ( who we don't know) bought over Rs 30. If they are related they  TFIL has to offer over Rs 30 .
     So this is mystery.
    3) these forerigners are  nuts

    4) these foreigner  are planning to sell  before Dec 4th ( but why should they sell cheaper than they bought?)


    1) If the company has to be delisted, TFIL has to be absorbed to COCR. That's why they are quoting a price 28/- as the mandatory price. After 4th December, they may halt trading, proceed with delisting.
    As of their last announcement, they hav 900K shares to be bought back for that and they will go ahead with the same figure since its unfair for the ppl who accept the manda offer if they raise the price and vice versa if they deduct it too. On the other hand its a must that they offer the highest price they bought to offer.
    Imo, in this case, the poor retailers who went after this like Tsunami are in trouble but company has nothing to do in this case.

    [url=/view/16185004/445]COCR to acquire TFIL -what are consequences ? - Page 2 Tfil10[/url]

    4) On 4th, its worthwhile to watch the drama unfolds.. As per above excerpt, all reaming shares would go to COCR at 28/-. I think it will take a month or so to receive the cheque though.

    On the other hand, if for some reason, TFIL come down than 27, the company might buy this time as they missed it at 26 (still 2 rupees profit for them than buying from the shareholders).

    Let me tell u what Im gonna do.. I dont a give a damn abt the foreigners.. I will buy some quantity if it hits below 26 or hold what I have till 4th December as selling to them at 28 is a profit even if this doesn't go to 30s..
    Missed a sure shot for a goal @ 24. Rolling Eyes
    But there is a time lag in materialising the profit.

      Current date/time is Sat Jun 22, 2024 8:16 am