The Investor Sentiment - Equity and investments forum for Sri Lankans
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 


Rechercher Advanced Search

Latest topics
» අනං මනං! #/+?.<>
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyToday at 6:10 pm by ruwan326

» Easter Sunday Attack and Sri Lanka
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyToday at 3:40 pm by ruwan326

» My Port Folio Bleeding But Its just the Begining Of..
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyYesterday at 7:40 pm by serene

» Thread for News on CSE and SL Economy
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyYesterday at 1:49 pm by ruwan326

» සදහම් අටුවාව
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyYesterday at 6:52 am by ruwan326

» HNB.N0000 ( Hatton National Bank PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri May 17, 2019 9:54 pm by dhanurrox

» Re: Financial reports Q1-2019
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri May 17, 2019 7:53 pm by dhanurrox

» Sri Lanka mulls 25-pct ownership limit in finance companies
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri May 17, 2019 3:40 pm by Backstage

» Searing Heat in China Is Causing Havoc for Rubber Makers
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri May 17, 2019 2:43 pm by Backstage

» COMB.N0000 ( COMMERCIAL BANK OF CEYLON PLC )
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu May 16, 2019 8:00 pm by hammurabi

» Dividend Announcement
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed May 15, 2019 6:42 pm by Rana

» Israeli spyware breached WhatsApp security
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed May 15, 2019 7:47 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Is Burka prohibted ?
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed May 15, 2019 7:30 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» Thread for General News Local/Foreign
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue May 14, 2019 11:49 am by CK

» Fed Rate hike , Rs Devaluation PART 2 : Should CSE be like this? Whose FAULT is it?
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri May 10, 2019 7:15 pm by Backstage

» NEST.N0000
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu May 09, 2019 7:54 pm by ruwan326

» What to Analyse
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu May 09, 2019 5:53 pm by Ethical Trader

» Sweden-based Tundra Fund says Colombo bourse at lowest levels since 2009
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed May 08, 2019 5:43 pm by serene

» Telenor and Dialog Axiata's parent in talks to merge Asian businesses
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyMon May 06, 2019 1:50 pm by Backstage

» සුබ පාස්කූ මංගල්ලයක් වේවා !
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySun May 05, 2019 6:51 pm by Backstage

» In the Meantime, Within Our Shores !
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu May 02, 2019 11:27 am by Ethical Trader

» LLUB.N0000 (CHEVRON LUBRICANTS LANKA PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed May 01, 2019 3:49 am by Ethical Trader

» Thread for News on Local and Foreign Politics
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 26, 2019 8:18 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» how to access internet ?
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 26, 2019 7:55 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» SERV - The Kingsbury
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu Apr 25, 2019 9:26 am by ruwan326

» Lessons from movies
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 23, 2019 8:26 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» DFCC.N0000 ( DFCC BANK PLC )
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyMon Apr 22, 2019 12:38 pm by ruwan326

» Happy Birthday
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySun Apr 21, 2019 8:13 pm by Rana

» Little Known Facts !
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySun Apr 21, 2019 9:27 am by කිත්සිරි ද සිල්වා

» හීන්බන්ඩාගේ රැකියාව ඇසූ පසු පොලිස් නෝනලාට තරු පෙනුනා
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySat Apr 20, 2019 10:07 am by ruwan326

» HASU.N0000 (HNB ASSURANCE PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu Apr 18, 2019 6:05 pm by Ethical Trader

» EAST WEST PROPERTIES PLC (EAST.N0000)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyThu Apr 18, 2019 6:02 pm by Ethical Trader

» අසිරිමත් සුබ නව වසරකට ආසිරි !
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed Apr 17, 2019 6:33 pm by hammurabi

» SEYLAN DEVELOPMENTS PLC (CSD.N0000)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 12, 2019 8:55 am by yellow knife

» East West properties
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 12, 2019 5:27 am by dhanurrox

» HHL.N0000 ( Hemas Holdings PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 09, 2019 8:04 pm by NIRMALSG

» කිරි පිටි ගැන ඔබ මෙතෙක් නොදත් දේ
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyMon Apr 08, 2019 5:31 am by Ethical Trader

» CONN.N0000
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySun Apr 07, 2019 3:15 pm by NIRMALSG

» LION.N0000 (Lion Brewery Ceylon PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptySun Apr 07, 2019 8:52 am by ruwan326

»  5000 Post Milestone - Congratulations
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 05, 2019 9:07 pm by Ethical Trader

» NTB.N0000 (NATIONS TRUST BANK PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 05, 2019 1:37 pm by Ethical Trader

» Micro Finance
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 05, 2019 12:14 pm by yellow knife

» REXP.N0000 ( RICHARD PIERIS EXPORTS PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyFri Apr 05, 2019 7:40 am by serene

» PLC.N0000 ( People's Leasing and Fiance PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed Apr 03, 2019 6:04 pm by NIRMALSG

» VPEL.N0000 (VALLIBEL POWER ERATHNA PLC )
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyWed Apr 03, 2019 3:40 pm by catseye

» SAMP.N0000 (SAMPATH BANK PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 02, 2019 12:38 pm by malanp

» Sinhala Cinema
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 02, 2019 12:31 pm by yellow knife

» SEYB.N0000 ( SEYLAN BANK PLC )
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 02, 2019 11:23 am by Backstage

» LIOC.N0000 (Lanka IOC PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 02, 2019 11:15 am by LSE

» NDB.N0000 (NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT BANK PLC)
Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls EmptyTue Apr 02, 2019 11:11 am by Backstage

May 2019
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Calendar Calendar

Disclaimer


Information posted in this forum are entirely of the respective members' personal views. The views posted on this open online forum of contributors do not constitute a recommendation buy or sell. The site nor the connected parties will be responsible for the posts posted on the forum and will take best possible action to remove any unlawful or inappropriate posts.
All rights to articles of value authored by members posted on the forum belong to the respective authors. Re-using without the consent of the authors is prohibited. Due credit with links to original source should be given when quoting content from the forum.
This is an educational portal and not one that gives recommendations. Please obtain investment advises from a Registered Investment Advisor through a stock broker

Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls

Go down

Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls Empty Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls

Post by The Invisible on Tue Oct 23, 2018 10:57 am

ECONOMYNEXT - Sri Lanka's State Minister for Economic Affairs Harsha de Silva, has re-kindled a debate as old as economics itself, repeating the advice David Ricardo once gave the Bank of England on sterilized gold sales in the early 19th century who also recalled the words of Adam Smith.

Sri Lanka's rupee started sliding in 2018, ending a controlled depreciation achieved in 2017, when dollar inflows were mopped up, and a de facto peg with the US dollar was anchored to a real effective exchange rate index. In the first quarter mopping up inflows suddenly ended weakening the peg.

Mopping up forex inflows (destroying money created by central bank when purchasing dollars) shrinks the real monetary base, keeping the 'circulating medium' below what is determined by the balance of payments, generating a strong peg, by contracting domestic credit, which is even stronger than a conventional currency board, analysts say.

However, sterilizing outflows of dollars (printing money to fill cash destroyed by dollar sales by the central bank) resists a contraction of the monetary base (and a rise in interest rates) as determined by the balance of payments, boosts domestic credit with printed money, leading to a continuous loss of forex reserves.

Sterilized Forex Sales Debate

"There’s been some discussion whether to have sterilized or unsterilized interventions, but in this instance I think it was sensible to try and keep a lid on interest rates and not allow interest rates to go sky high," Dushni Weerakoon, Executive Director of the Institute of Policy Studies, a Colombo-based think tank, said at an economic forum earlier this month.

"Because at this time increase of interest rates is not going to stop the exit of investors from T-bills and bonds or the opposite - inflows of new investments."

De Silva, an economist before he became a politician, said he was not asking for sky high rates, but at least to allow rates to go up to 8.50 percent ceiling overnight policy rate and the rest of the yield curve to be market determined.

"I slightly differ from Dushni’s viewpoint whether we should sterilize more or less in interventions in the forex market," he said.

"As you now see, overnight call money rates have almost hit the ceiling at 8.5 percent.

"If it is hitting the ceiling and you’re not injecting money at below 8.5 percent, then it’s alright and there’s no need currently to increase your policy rates.

"But at least let the overnight rates be within the higher margin of the policy rate. It’s prudent.

"Of course it’s going to have a negative impact on growth, but that is what we have to give to have some sort of stability on the exchange rate."

The central bank is still injecting printed money at 8.4 percent and longer term money below the Sri Lanka Interbank Offered Rates, subsidizing the hit on the currency but even that rate is over three times that of the Federal Reserve.

"This is a debate that is going on," De Silva said.

"I trust the economists at the central bank are thinking about this and are trying to balance the two sides."

De Silva, has been strong critic of the central bank when it was sterilizing interventions and triggering balance of payments crises in the past.

As a government minister he has been careful not to undermine confidence in the agency or its current Governor who commands widespread respect, but is trying to nudge it towards more prudent policy.

De Silva said there was an overshooting of the exchange rate and fundamentals of the economy were strong.

Neo-Mercantilism

De Silva's advice not to sterilize foreign exchange interventions (or at least limit sterilization by allowing rates to go up) has been given to the Bank of England by classical economists like David Ricardo in the early 1800s, when the Bank of England's soft-peg (with gold) broke.

The Bank of England suspended gold convertibility in 1797 (floated the pound), after credibility in its gold peg was lost, generating a run on gold.

Analysts say economics per se was defeated after World War II with Neo-Mercantilism coming back to the fore, with the US Treasury and State Department setting up the Bretton Woods system of failed soft-pegs and convincing people that it could work amid Keynesianism.

Large numbers of people, who are perfectly rational otherwise, again now believe that trade or current account deficits rather than monetary instability trigger currency depreciation as in the time of classical Mercantilism or as David Ricardo called it, "an evil of such magnitude."

Post World War II Mercantilists turned their backs on sound economics put forward by the likes of David Ricardo (or Adam Smith) at the beginning of their profession, which then led to widespread currency troubles and trade restrictions as bad or worse than the inter war years that the architects of the Bretton Woods were hoping to avoid.

High Price of Gold/Dollars

Ricardo explained that when gold was money (circulating medium), if a new gold mine was discovered, it will expand money supply and reduce the price of gold.

This will lead to the export of gold (in exchange for some other article) to countries where gold was more 'expensive', until gold prices 'went up' again the in the country with the gold mine, which is similar to an unsterilized sale.

"In return for the gold exported, commodities would be imported; and though what is usually termed the balance of trade would be against the country exporting money or bullion…," Ricardo explained in the High Price of Bullion, a Proof of the Depreciation of Bank Notes in 1809.

"If instead of a mine being discovered in any country, a bank were established, such as the Bank of England, with the power of issuing its notes for a circulating medium; after a large amount had been issued either by way of loan to merchants (such as modern day term reverse repo deals with banks), or by advances to government (directly buying Treasury bills at Wednesday's auction), thereby adding considerably to the sum of the currency, the same effect would follow as in the case of the mine."

"The circulating medium would be lowered in value, and goods would experience a proportionate rise.

"The equilibrium between that and other nations would only be restored by the exportation of part of the coin."

Regardless of what happened to the money supplies of other countries, Ricardo explained that as long the Bank of England was prepared to pay gold for the notes later (unsterilized gold sales), it could buy gold for notes (unsterilized purchases).

However if new notes were re-issued (if the gold sale was sterilized) and the contraction of reserve money was resisted, the exchange rate will weaken again.

"[I]f the Bank assuming, that because a given quantity of circulating medium had been necessary last year, therefore the same quantity must be necessary (resists a contraction in the monetary base) this, or for any other reason (push growth in modern Keynesian terms, bring rates down), continued to re-issue the returned notes, the stimulus which a redundant currency first gave to the exportation of the coin would be again renewed with similar effects; gold would be again demanded, the exchange would become unfavourable.."

If the bank continued to be sterilize interventions (fill with new money keeping rates down), all gold reserves would eventually be lost in classing balance of payments crisis.

"In this manner if the Bank persisted in returning their notes into circulation, every guinea might be drawn out of their coffers."

Penelope's Web

Ricardo also explained that buying gold in the market and coining them will not solve the problem either.

"If to supply the deficiency of their stock of gold they were to purchase gold bullion at the advanced price, and have it coined into guineas, this would not remedy the evil, guineas would be still demanded, but instead of being exported would be melted and sold to the Bank as bullion at the advanced price," he wrote.

""The operations of the Bank,” observed Dr Smith, alluding to an analogous case, ”were upon this account somewhat like the web of Penelope, the work that was done in the day was undone in the night.""

Penelope was the wife of Odyssues who was ostensibly weaving a shroud for her dying father in law, and undoing her work in the night, so that the cloth would not be finished and she would not have to accept another suitor and remain unmarried her husband returned.

Adam Smith was referring to a case where debased coins were in circulation, and people were melting good coins and exporting them and the bank was minting more new coins with the correct value of gold and releasing them causing them to be melted again.

People could also melt coins and sell gold to the bank itself, repeating the cycle all over again.

This was somewhat 'analogous' in concept to a modern soft-pegged bank entering into Soros swaps, with new money which will be used to hit the peg.

Buying dollars from the Treasury in the midst of currency pressure, releasing new money into the banking system to hit the peg again is also 'analogous' to the Penelope's web, analysts say.

De Silva had also urged the central bank not to engage in Soros-style swaps.

Mercantilist Whipping Boys

In modern Sri Lanka the whipping boy for monetary stability is motor vehicles current account deficits. In Ricardo's time it was corn imports (grain) and merchandise trade deficits. In Sri Lanka gold imported and re-exported (smuggled) to India has also become an additional Mercantilist distraction.

Sri Lanka recently slapped controls on vehicles and some items like footware as the rupee fell due to contradictory policy, leaving the administration's case for free trade in tatters and with advocates of open markets with egg on their faces.

"I’m not in favour of restrictions," de Silva said.

"If the government goes and puts restrictions on trade, obviously its's counterproductive to the argument that we’re making that we want to create a conducive trade regime.

"We need to address aggregate demand."

De Silva was again echoing the words of Ricardo on monetary instability: The exportation of the coin is caused by its cheapness and is not the effect, but the cause of an unfavourable balance."

Despite Ricardo's work, so-called Corn Laws were enacted to protect domestic farmers, who were powerful politically.

The Corn Laws were abolished in 1846, by Prime Minister Robert Peel, two years after a law was brought to restrain note issuing banks (the Peel Act). (Colombo/Oct23/2018)
The Invisible
The Invisible

Posts : 883
Join date : 2016-11-28
Age : 39

Back to top Go down

Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls Empty Re: Sri Lanka's Dr de Silva re-kindles debate on Ricardo's evil and Penelope's web of Dr Smith as rupee falls

Post by Brave Heart on Wed Oct 24, 2018 11:23 am

Thanks Invi.

Brave Heart

Posts : 171
Join date : 2018-10-17

Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum